No items found.
Right side up logoRight side up logo

Why AI Accelerates Expertise Instead of Replacing It with Jonathan Metrick

Published

November 19, 2026

“AI is going to allow experts to do more, better, faster, cheaper, but you still have this governing tastemaker quality control.”

In this episode of Growth Talks, Jonathan Metrick, a 4x CMO and VC & PE Operating Partner at Sagard, joins Right Side Up’s GM of the Offline Practice and host Krystina Rubino to share what he’s learned helping more than 100 portfolio companies grow. Before Sagard, Jonathan was CMO of Policygenius, where he built a 45-person growth division and helped increase revenue 10x ahead of the company’s acquisition.

Jonathan explains why the right growth strategy usually maps back to what the founder is great at, why copying a competitor’s playbook from the outside burns capital, and why AI accelerates expertise rather than replacing it. He also shares the story of a portfolio CMO who put his team on an “AI embargo” and lays out when a company is really ready to hire a CMO.

🗝️ Key Takeaways

  • Build growth around your founder’s superpower. EEngineering-led companies like Shopify solve problems with product, while brand-driven founders lean into editorial and brand activations. Founders who love a motion can hire, retain, and invest in great talent for it.
  • Get best in class at one or two channels. A study Jonathan published in TechCrunch found businesses usually have two primary growth channels driving over 50% of their lead volume. The more you scale them, the more cost-effective they get and the bigger the moat.‍
  • Don’t copy a competitor’s playbook from the outside. You can’t see whether it’s working or why they’re doing it. At Policygenius, a competitor’s heavy display and retargeting spend sparked board pressure to follow—and the competitor ratcheted it down six months later.‍
  • AI accelerates expertise, but you still need the expertise. A creative director with a decade of experience can use AI to speed up versioning, editing, and sizing because they know what good looks like. Someone who has never made ads can’t.
  • Don’t hire too senior too soon. At $3 million to $5 million in ARR, you need hands-on, tactical marketing help. A CMO makes sense once you’ve found product-market fit, have a team already running marketing, and need to unlock growth across functions.

⏰ Timestamps

01:13 - Introducing Jonathan Metrick
02:52 - Why founder superpowers shape your growth strategy
06:37 - Finding and doubling down on your natural superpower
09:28 - Scaling a personal superpower into an organizational capability
11:48 - Why copying competitors’ playbooks burns capital
15:11 - AI accelerates expertise, it doesn’t replace it
20:03 - Where AI creates real leverage: content, analysis, and GEO
24:45 - Arbitrage windows in LLM visibility and affiliate strategy
29:13 - The CMO who instituted an AI embargo
31:33 - Automating the work you don’t want to do
36:19 - The A/B Test: attribution vs. incrementality and more
44:41 - Operating partner vs. interim operator
50:36 - How to know when you’re ready for a CMO
52:57 - Favorite growth non-hack: know your ICP

🔗 Mentioned in this episode‍

Sagard: https://www.sagard.com/
Policygenius: https://www.policygenius.com/
Shopify: https://www.shopify.com/‍

We'll be dropping episodes every other week. Want to follow along and listen to new episodes when they're released? Subscribe to Growth Talks on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts.

FAQ

How can a company identify its primary growth channels?

A company’s strongest growth channels often map back to what its founder is naturally great at. Jonathan Metrick noticed the pattern across a portfolio of more than 100 businesses: engineering-driven founders, like Shopify’s, tend to solve problems with product, while creative founders lean into editorial and brand activations from day one. Founders who are passionate about a motion can hire, retain, and invest in strong talent for it. A useful gut check is asking what you’d happily work on over a weekend or late into the evening. From there, the goal is to choose one or two primary channels deliberately, build a team and repeatable process around them, and go from good to excellent.

Why is it risky to copy a competitor’s growth strategy?

From the outside, you can’t tell whether a competitor’s tactic is working or why they’re doing it. At Policygenius, a competitor spent heavily on display advertising and retargeting, which led to board pressure to follow, even though Jonathan’s team had already tested those channels and found they didn’t pay out. Six months later, the competitor ratcheted down that spend. Brand spend can mislead, too: Jonathan has seen companies turn off brand to improve unit economics before a fundraise, and others spike it to show awareness and traction. Companies that chase a rival’s motion without the talent, knowledge, or passion to run it are where he’s seen a lot of capital get burned.

Where is AI creating real leverage for marketing teams right now?

AI is earning its keep in three areas, according to Jonathan. The first is content creation: writing, editing, versioning, and even compliance reviews on ads. The second is analysis, including paid media analysis, lead scoring and prioritization, and enriching ICP information—second-order work most teams never had enough analysts to do. The third is AI search and GEO. As LLMs change how people discover products, businesses of every size want to know whether those tools recommend them, and he calls it probably the number one AI topic he hears across the marketing stack. Because there’s no proven playbook yet, he sees an arbitrage window for early testers until everyone else catches up.

Which AI projects should marketing teams prioritize?

The strongest AI use cases target work that’s time-intensive and happens frequently, which creates feedback loops and raises the likelihood of ROI. Often it’s the part of the job people most wish they could get rid of, like cutting a spot into versions and sizes for Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok, or doing daily cross-channel paid media analysis. A one-off project, like a Super Bowl ad made once every two years, is a poor fit. Jonathan also shares the story of a portfolio CMO who paused new AI builds and sunset tools only one or two people used, so the team could focus on solutions that work 100% of the time and materially improve P&L, revenue, or cost.

When is a company ready to hire a CMO?

A company is ready for a CMO once it has product-market fit, is scaling, and already has a team running marketing relatively well. At that stage, a CMO up-levels the full infrastructure, works cross-functionally with the CRO, CPO, and CFO, and brings in benchmarks from other teams and industries. Before then, Jonathan cautions against hiring too senior too soon. Because fewer than 10% of CEOs have worked in marketing, founders often assume needing marketing means needing a CMO. Depending on the stage, the right hire might be a scrappy generalist, a marketing director, or a VP. At $3 million to $5 million in ARR, his view is that you need tactical, hands-on help, not a CMO.

Episode Transcript

Let's talk growth

Get in touch

Let's talk growth

Get in touch

Let's talk growth

Get in touch

Hungry for growth?

Sign up for growth marketing insights delivered straight to your inbox